The Box Office Limitations Of ‘Toy Story 4’ Spell Mixed News For Pixar Fans

toy story 4

Toy Story 4 is doing well at the box office. Three weeks into its release, the sequel has earned over $650 million worldwide, with a good chunk of that being made domestically (which means higher profits for Disney and Pixar).

Soon, Toy Story 4 will surpass Finding Nemo and Inside Out at the domestic box office, but it might only just barely catch up to Toy Story 3. It stands no chance of making the same amount as Finding Dory and Incredibles 2, which are two of the highest grossing animated films of all time.

This is a bit…unexpected. Box office prognosticators like myself predicted a much stronger showing for Toy Story 4, one that would at least keep pace with Finding Dory. Why? It’s a summer release, Toy Story is a beloved franchise, reviews have been stellar, and it’s been almost a decade since the last film. These were all factors that contributed to the massive box office success of Incredibles 2 in 2018 and Finding Dory in 2016.

The same just isn’t happening for Toy Story 4.

To reiterate, the film is doing extremely well by Pixar standards. Just not Pixar sequel standards (disregarding Cars 3, of course). The film should be outperforming Toy Story 3, taking into account inflation. What was $1 billion in 2010 amounts to a far greater sum in 2019. Pixar made Toy Story 4 with the hopes that it would make more profit, not about the same or slightly less.

It’s hard to pin down what’s precisely contributing to this underperformance. It’s been a weak year for animated movies overall at the box office, especially sequels. How to Train Your Dragon 3, The Lego Movie 2, and The Secret Life of Pets 2 have all done far worse business than their predecessors, even with good reviews on their side.

No matter the exact reason, at least one thing is clear. Pixar and Disney now have to reckon with the reality that the sequel gravy train isn’t as long-lasting as they might have hoped. New Pixar sequels won’t necessarily be huge moneymakers, for reasons that are admittedly nebulous and unpredictable. There’s a ceiling to how many movies Pixar can deliver within a single franchise before moviegoers get bored. Audiences just don’t seem to be as invested in a fourth Toy Story as they would be a fourth Avengers film, apparently.

But this is good news for Pixar fans. By and large, we want more original films from the studio, and the underperformance of Toy Story 4 lends credence to artists who want to challenge resourcing decisions. They can now argue that a slew of original Pixar films is badly needed in order to refresh their existing IP in the years before we get an Incredibles 3 or Inside Out 2, which are probably the only sequels most audiences would be curious to see anytime soon.

That said, there’s also a downside to Pixar rethinking their lineup of films in the latter half of the next decade (keep in mind, their next four films are already originals). Yes, they have new incentive to focus on original films because sequels to existing sequels simply aren’t guaranteed hits, but this unearths a new problem. What if Pixar stops making as many original films that don’t have to be franchise starters?

Put more simply, Pixar might stop making films like Coco and WALL-E because stories like that are too standalone in a cinematic landscape where franchises practically rule the box office. Why green light the next Ratatouille or Up when more resources and effort can be put into the next Incredibles, which is a film with so much spectacle, you can’t help but want it to continue.

My worry is that the next truly great original idea for a Pixar film might be tossed aside in favor of something more financially feasible. Or worse, an original idea might be tampered with in order to fit a sequel paradigm outside its intended draw. This is all speculation, and we simply don’t know what Disney and Pixar are truly considering for their next creative output. But we know they’re paying careful attention to what is making money at the box office right now. And they’re not films with satisfying conclusions. They’re films that never really end.

14 thoughts on “The Box Office Limitations Of ‘Toy Story 4’ Spell Mixed News For Pixar Fans

  1. That’s a very good point about the viability of films that are not franchise starters. I really don’t want to see Pixar turning away from something that could be great. THat’s why I am not disappointed with Toy Story’s “failure” in the box office. By the way, those sarcasm quotes are dripping with extra sarcasm today.

    • I haven’t seen anyone I respect try and call it a “failure” for obvious reasons, but I’m sure there are those out there with this strange opinion.

  2. You are forgetting that Toy Story 4 outgrossed Moana, Ralph 2 and Coco, Disney has no business being exigent about it. Also, something tells me they aren’t surprised at its box office after how little impact the trailers had in the public.

    • Yes, but you are comparing Toy Story 4 to original films that were never expected to make well over $1 billion at the box office. Even Ralph 2 was a sequel to a film that couldn’t even manage half a billion in 2012. Disney and Pixar aren’t using those films as benchmarks, they’re looking at Incredibles 2 and Finding Dory, the two Pixar sequels that proved a pattern they wanted to see continued with Toy Story 4. We know Disney/Pixar has to be surprised at the limited box office because it came in well under their own projections.

  3. What you share is what I seek. provided me with a great deal of knowledge. hope that you will make more efforts to have more excellent articles!
    among us

  4. I didn’t have any expectations concerning that title, but the more I was astonished. The author did a great job. I spent a few minutes reading and checking the facts. Everything is very clear and understandable. I like posts that fill in your knowledge gaps. This one is of the sort.

  5. That is a really valid point concerning the viability of movies that don’t establish a series. I just don’t want to see Pixar rejecting a potential masterpiece.

  6. After wathching “Toy story 4” two times, I realized it’s a fantastic io games movie but as a follow-up, it is a perfect example of how to advance franchise storytelling.

  7. Pixar might stop making films like Coco and WALL-E because stories like that are too standalone in a cinematic landscape where franchises practically rule the box office.

  8. Share about extremely good and attractive movies. Beautiful and funny characters. If you have any free time visit the page fall guys to enjoy these great games!

  9. On moving day, make sure to be present and available to answer any questions the movers may have. Take inventory of all your belongings to ensure that nothing gets lost or damaged during the move. Once everything is packed up and ready to go, do a final walkthrough of your old home to make sure you haven’t forgotten anything. Three Movers Crunchbase

  10. Excellent post. This is, in my opinion, one of the best posts that you have made. Your work is quite outstanding in both quality and quantity. I am grateful to you for it.

Leave a Reply

%d bloggers like this: