How ‘Moana’ Finally Settled The Disney Princess Debate

disney princess

Disney’s Moana was a fantastic animated musical, and one of the main reasons why has to do with its handling of the female protagonist, Moana herself.

The animation studio was essentially founded on the cornerstone of the “princess” being a driving force of fairy tale movies, which eventually evolved into increasingly more diverse types of stories. Specifically, Snow White laid the groundwork as one of the best films of all time (animated or otherwise), as well Disney’s first feature film. And they later built upon this with Cinderella and Sleeping Beauty as smart ways to repeat Snow White‘s massive success.

This ended up being a saving grace for Disney after multiple near-catastrophes with bad box office, animator strikes, and so on, though Walt still believed in experimenting with non-princess movies like Peter PanPinocchioDumbo, and of course, Mary Poppins.

Long after his death in 1966, the Disney Princess transformed from an idea to an actual media franchise worth an insane amount of money and indicative of Disney’s influence over generations of children. In the early 2000s, it became an official thing, combining the classic Disney princesses of the old days with recent heroines of the 90s renaissance. And the criteria, at the time, was confusing to say the least.

disney princess

Obviously, Snow White, Cinderella, and Aurora were “inducted” into the official Disney Princess brand. Joining them was Ariel from The Little Mermaid, another obvious choice though different in the sense that she’s royalty of an underwater culture. Then Belle from Beauty and the Beast, who doesn’t technically become a princess until the very end of the movie.

Jasmine from Aladdin was another obvious choice, though striking because she was the first Disney princess to be nonwhite, and she’s more of a supporting character than a lead protagonist. Jasmine was followed up by two consecutive nonwhite Disney princesses, though: Pocahontas and Mulan. Though Tinker Bell from Peter Pan was technically a Disney Princess for a short time before getting replaced by Tiana and becoming a home video sensation.

They didn’t include Nala or Kiara from Lion King, which seems to be because animals simply don’t qualify. Same goes for Esmerelda from Hunchback of Notre Dame because she’s technically a gypsy, Megara from Hercules, and Jane from Tarzan. The first “modern” princess was Tiana from Princess and the Frog, then Rapunzel from Tangled was added as the first CG character. And the last Disney Princess in the official sense is Merida from Brave, a Pixar movie rather than a Walt Disney Animation one.

disney princess

These are the “official” Disney princesses, but that hasn’t stopped many other fans from considering the wider breadth of characters to fit the bill. Simply because the criteria isn’t always consistent (like with Tinker Bell and Mulan not being royalty). Eventually, Anna from Frozen will be added along with Moana, but no one really believes their status as princesses is held back until Disney slaps their own label on it and has their clique running around Disney World.

A lot of this might sound a bit silly and inconsequential, but there are actually heated debates held by…some…who argue over which Disney female characters are “allowed” to be called Disney princesses. And this is a big deal, in part, because countless kids look to the mainstream Disney princesses as a representation of themselves in these movies. Parents want their kids to have positive role models, and the Disney princesses, like it or not, are a major cultural force in that regard.

The more recent Disney princess from CG animated films definitely fit the more literal interpretation of what’s become such a pervasive line of business for these animated films. But Moana subtly settles this debate, I believe, once and for all. It points out that the semantics don’t matter, really, as Disney seems intent on including future princesses as it sees fit.

moana

The pivotal line between Maui and Moana is what specifically points this out. Maui tells Moana she is a “princess,” but she denies this because she’s actually the daughter of a Chief (the literal view). But Maui banters back with self-awareness on the writers’ part:

“If you wear a dress and have an animal sidekick, then you’re a princess.” 

What he really seems to be saying here is that it doesn’t really matter. What makes these characters “princesses” has very little to do with royal bloodlines and more with the tropes that Disney infuses in its protagonists and supporting characters. A dress and an animal sidekick are incredibly broad. so Disney can in effect say from here on out that there’s no reason to overthink this merchandising franchise they’re so clearly benefiting from.

And that’s fine because it allows Disney to incorporate as many different cultures, hair colors, and clothing styles as they can with their princess characters, but not at the expense of the story making sense. Or worse, always falling back on traditional princess tales instead of doing something as “culturealistic” as Moana and Mulan.

moana

Moving forward, I like to think that this line by Maui was allowed in the movie because they’re acknowledging how limiting it is to hold back the Disney Princess inclusivity for the sake of being so literal. It’s not relevant how these characters look on a family tree, but rather that they’re interesting characters who follow a consistent aesthetic and type of storytelling that’s proven incredibly successful for Disney since the 30s. Maybe one day, it won’t even be questioned whether or not a Disney princess is one because she wears a dress, especially if you consider the fact that they included Merida, a princess who is usually shown with her bow and arrow rather than a bucket of glitter.

But one thing’s for certain. The best Disney princess is obviously Lilo.


Thanks for reading this. To get updates on my theories, books, and giveaways, join my Mailing List.

Or just say hey on Twitter: @JonNegroni


226 thoughts on “How ‘Moana’ Finally Settled The Disney Princess Debate

  1. I really appreciate the depth you go into with this topic! I’ve explored a related subject on my blog and thought it could provide some additional value to your readers. Here’s the link if you’re interested!
    progeeks.co.za

  2. This is a really comprehensive guide! I recently wrote about a related aspect on my site, and I thought you might find it interesting. Feel free to check it out when you get a chance!
    Sonic Happy Hour Time

  3. I’m loving the way you’ve structured this article! You’ve made a complicated topic so easy to understand. I wrote a similar guide on my site, and I think it could be helpful for your readers too. Would love for you to take a look!
    menuland.uk

  4. This is an incredibly detailed post! I especially liked your points on [specific detail]. I recently tackled a similar topic on my blog and thought it might provide some additional insights for your readers. Here’s the link if you’re interested!
    emiratesera.com

  5. This is a really comprehensive guide! I recently wrote about a related aspect on my site, and I thought you might find it interesting. Feel free to check it out when you get a chance!
    Multi brawl

  6. A key advantage of Lightroom is its ability to handle RAW images. This format preserves the highest quality of the photo, giving users full control over every detail during the editing process without losing clarity.
    https://lightroapk.org/lightroom-for-pc/

  7. Globe SIM registration is a required process for all Globe users in the Philippines to enhance mobile security and prevent fraud. In compliance with the SIM Registration Act (Republic Act 11934), all users must register their SIM cards using valid identification to continue using Globe services. This ensures seamless access to calls, texts, data, and financial platforms like GCash.
    Globe SIM registration

  8. “The Disney Princess Debate is always an exciting topic—whether it’s about who’s the most iconic or who deserves to be on top, each princess has her own unique qualities that make her special. It’s the perfect discussion for any Disney fan! And if you’re in the mood for a Disney movie marathon afterward, just film app descargar and enjoy all your favorite princess stories at the touch of a button!”

  9. After finally settling the Disney Princess debate, it feels like finding the perfect balance in stardew valley apk—whether it’s tending to your farm or building relationships, there’s always a satisfying sense of resolution. Just like how Disney characters have their own charm, each aspect of Stardew Valley brings something unique to the table, making the game (and debate) enjoyable in its own way!

  10. The Roblox Mega Menu is a feature within the Roblox platform that provides players with quick access to a wide range of tools, settings, and options to enhance their gaming experience. Accessed through an in-game interface, the Mega Menu allows users to manage their avatar, adjust settings, view friends, and access the Roblox catalog, among other features. visit rubloxapk.com

  11. Moana is such an inspiring character! 🌊 Her adventurous spirit reminds me of trying new things—like Sonic’s Boba drinks! 🧋 If you love tropical flavors, you might enjoy these Sonic Boba Drink

  12. Are you ready to test your mental strength and challenge yourself like never before? Introducing MemoryTestGame, the ultimate platform designed to push your limits and unlock the full potential of your brain! Whether you’re a casual gamer, a student, or someone looking to sharpen their cognitive skills, MemoryTestGame offers an array of engaging activities that will keep your mind active and entertained.

  13. Shadow Fight 2 is an epic blend of RPG and fighting game mechanics! The combat feels so smooth and satisfying, and the shadow energy system adds a unique twist. https://shadowfight2modaapk.com/

  14. Craving a delicious pizza but not sure what to order? Check out the Pizza Express menuPizza Express menu for a variety of mouthwatering options, from classic Margherita to gourmet vegan choices! Find your perfect pizza and let me know your favorite in the comments!

  15. Jenny Mod is such a creative and fun twist on Minecraft! It adds a unique storyline and characters that make the game even more engaging. Perfect for players looking for something different and narrative-driven jenny mod minecraft

  16. The performance is smooth, and it’s amazing how much functionality they’ve packed into a mobile version pocket edition

    .

  17. FilmAppAPK provides a simple interface for streaming movies and TV shows. With a vast library of content, users can easily watch their favorite films and enjoy uninterrupted entertainment on Android devices.

  18. https://monark.com.pk/collections/formal-shirts
    Monark Clothing’s dress shirts combine sleek design with superior comfort, making them a standout choice for any wardrobe. Their elegant stitching and premium fabric reflect true craftsmanship and style.

  19. jojoyprovides fast, safe, and secure downloads for modded apps and games.

  20. This blog provides an insightful overview of Disney’s evolving princess franchise, highlighting Moana’s significance in the lineup. Much like a timeless polo shirt https://monark.com.pk/collections/polo-shirts that blends classic appeal with modern versatility, Moana embodies both tradition and innovation in Disney’s storytelling.

  21. This blog provides an insightful look into Disney’s evolving portrayal of princesses, highlighting Moana’s role in redefining the modern heroine. Just as Disney has adapted its princesses to reflect diversity and growth, a good skincare https://pharmahealth.com.pk/collections/skin-care routine evolves to meet the changing needs of healthy, radiant skin.

  22. To pay a ticket using NJMCDirect, you need to have a few key details handy: the traffic ticket number, the court ID, and your vehicle’s license plate number. Once these are entered into the system, the platform retrieves your ticket information and displays the amount due. Payments can then be made via debit or credit card.

Leave a Reply

Discover more from Jon Negroni

Subscribe now to keep reading and get access to the full archive.

Continue reading